Observed Signal · Sep 17, 2026 · Industry Event Summary · Source: AdExchanger · Impact: 3/5 · Sentiment: Positive
Retail Media Must Prove Incrementality for Broader Budgets
Retail media is maturing beyond its role as a performance channel for capturing existing demand. At Ascendant Network's inaugural SHOWCASE upfront, the industry discussed the need for retail media to create demand, not just capture it. Key themes included the shift from closed-loop attribution to incrementality measurement, and the need for standardized metrics across commerce media networks to allow advertisers to compare performance. DoorDash Ads highlighted a partnership with Circana showing that 56% of its buyers were net-new customers for a major beverage brand. DoorDash also earned certification from the Alliance for Audited Media for its incrementality measurement, underscoring the push for independent validation and accountability to compete for broader marketing budgets.
Highlights the maturation of retail media with a push for incrementality and standardization, impacting how budgets are allocated across the industry.
Track Circana Signals & Market Shifts in Real-Time
Polaris7 autonomous intelligence agents track regulatory filings, primary sources, executive changes, and deal flow 24/7. Create your Polaris7 workspace to monitor these entities.
Key Takeaways & Evidence Grounding
- Ascendant Network held its inaugural Retail + Commerce Media Upfront called SHOWCASE in September 2026.
- DoorDash collaborated with Circana to measure incremental in-store sales driven by advertising.
- 56% of buyers reached through DoorDash were net-new customers for a major beverage brand.
- DoorDash earned certification from the Alliance for Audited Media for its first-party incrementality measurement.
- Two-thirds of DoorDash users are undecided about what to buy when they open the app.
Connected Companies & Entities
“DoorDash Ads recently worked with Circana to show that advertising for a major beverage company drove incremental in-store sales.”
“Two-thirds of DoorDash users are still undecided about what to buy when they open the app.”
Ontology Mapping & Concepts
Related Market Signals & Shifts
Recent verified developments and strategic activity across this market segment.
Incrementality and Ghost Ads Tackle Retail Media Measurement
Retail media spend and networks are rapidly expanding, but measurement remains fragmented and often relies on attribution models that can over-credit ads for sales that would have occurred anyway. The article argues that incrementality — experiment-based measurement of causal lift — is the right approach to determine true advertising impact. Ghost ads, a method that preserves auction dynamics by serving neutral placeholders to control groups, are highlighted as an effective way to create valid controls in retail media. DoorDash is named as an early adopter of ghost ads in retail lift studies; the article reports a 92% reduction in experimentation dilution and a 35% improvement in ROAS confidence intervals after implementing ghost ads. Wider adoption of incrementality approaches could improve budget allocation, platform accountability, and trust across the retail media ecosystem.
Retail Media Networks Showcase Differentiation Strategies at Ascendant Showcase
At Ascendant Network's Showcase event in New York City, 11 retail media networks presented strategies to differentiate themselves to advertisers. Executives from The Home Depot's Orange Apron Media, Albertsons, DoorDash, PayPal, Macy's, Chase, Dick's Sporting Goods, Instacart, Chewy, Walgreens, H-E-B, and others highlighted unique strengths such as first-party data, audience insights, omnichannel reach, and content partnerships. Common themes included demonstrating incrementality, reaching consumers across the funnel, leveraging transaction data, and creating engaging content. The event underscored the intensifying competitive landscape of retail media as networks vie for ad dollars and seek to prove value beyond basic sponsored product listings.
Retail Media Evolution Starts With Smarter Questions
At an ADWEEK House Cannes Lions panel co-hosted with CVS Media Exchange (CMX), industry leaders argued retail media must move beyond raw data volume toward clearer goals and actionable measurement. Parbinder Dhariwal (CVS Media Exchange) said brands are drowning in data and need defined objectives—incrementality, category growth, new‑to‑brand acquisition, and retention—to turn signals into decisions. Cara Pratt (Circana) urged building data strategy into decision-making up front and highlighted cross‑retailer measurement: Circana’s work with CMX showed incremental ROAS that flowed to purchases at retailers outside CVS. Panelists also flagged in‑store, short‑visit shopper moments as an underused retail media opportunity and called for using end‑to‑end transaction data to inform broader marketing strategy beyond single campaigns.
Receive all future signals for Circana & competitors in your briefing
Never miss material M&A deals, leadership changes, account wins, or product rollouts. Polaris7 monitors 20,000+ primary sources 24/7, delivering verified telemetry directly into your executive briefing.
