Observed Signal · Sep 24, 2026 · Research Publication · Source: The Drum · Impact: 2/5 · Sentiment: Negative
Agencies and brands disagree on service delivery, study finds
New research by The Drum and iResearch Services, presented at The Drum Live, reveals a significant gap between how agencies and brands perceive agency performance. While 77% of agency leaders believe they deliver what brands want, only 23% of brand marketers agree, and 47% actively disagree. The study, based on a global poll of 600 senior marketers (averaging $346M in revenue), also found that over three-quarters of brand marketers expect to bring brand strategy in-house by 2030, whereas less than half of agency leaders agree. Additionally, AI is a growing focus: 59% of brand-side marketers rank deep AI expertise as the most in-demand agency skill, and 71% expect AI to significantly shape workflows by 2030, with 45% predicting a human-AI hybrid model. Despite AI-driven efficiency expectations, 80% of marketers still foresee rising marketing costs by 2030. The Drum Live panel, featuring industry leaders like Michele Rousseau and Ajaz Ahmed, emphasized the need for agencies to challenge briefs and deliver cultural insight.
Highlights a significant industry perception gap that could impact agency business models, relevant to AdTech and marketing.
Track Starling Signals & Market Shifts in Real-Time
Polaris7 autonomous intelligence agents track regulatory filings, primary sources, executive changes, and deal flow 24/7. Create your Polaris7 workspace to monitor these entities.
Key Takeaways & Evidence Grounding
- 77% of agency leaders believe they deliver what brands want, but only 23% of brand marketers agree (47% actively disagree).
- The Drum and iResearch Services' 'Mind The Gap' report surveyed 600 senior marketers globally (director level+), with an average company revenue of $346M. The report was released on September 25, 2026.
- 80% of brand marketers expect brand strategy to be handled in-house by 2030, compared to 49% of agency leaders.
- 59% of brand-side marketers identified deep AI expertise as the most in-demand agency skill, and 71% expect AI to significantly shape workflows by 2030.
- 69% of brands and 56% of agencies believe AI will improve profitability, but 80% of marketers still foresee rising marketing costs by 2030.
Connected Companies & Entities
“Michele Rousseau, chief marketing officer at Starling Bank, discussed the gap.”
Ontology Mapping & Concepts
Related Market Signals & Shifts
Recent verified developments and strategic activity across this market segment.
Brand Side Offers Better Job Satisfaction Than Agencies
A NewtonX survey conducted for ADWEEK finds agency-side employees report lower job satisfaction and greater appetite to leave compared with brand-side marketers. The data show 53% of brand marketers plan to remain in their roles for the next 12 months, while 54% of agency executives expect to go independent or start their own firms within two years. Agency staff report lower job security (44% vs. 56%) and worse work–life balance (55% vs. 65%). The article links these trends to industry consolidation, budget cuts (including WPP’s £400M reduction), tighter marketing budgets, and differing perceptions of AI—agencies view AI as a headcount risk, brands view it as a productivity tool.
GWA Study: CMOs Shift In-House, Agencies Need New Models
The German Association of Advertising Agencies (GWA) has published a white paper titled "The New Value. Agencies in the Tension Between AI Maturity and Customer Expectations." Based on surveys of 170 CEOs/CMOs and 78 agency executives, the study reveals that 80% of marketing decision-makers plan to move more work in-house thanks to AI, particularly in research (52%), creative (50%), and production (44%). However, only 8% expect agency roles to shrink, suggesting agencies will take on new strategic and integration tasks. The study highlights that AI is deeply embedded in agency workflows, with 76% having AI-based offerings, yet 67% cite talent shortages as a top hurdle. It challenges assumptions that AI lowers costs, pointing to new costs in licenses, infrastructure, and governance. Only 10% of companies have fully integrated AI into their processes, indicating an industry in transition.
Agencies Say AI Adoption Outpaces Advertisers
Agency leaders at Cannes Lions told Digiday that agencies are further advanced in AI adoption than their brand clients. Executives described agencies building sophisticated internal AI tooling and platforms while many CMOs remain constrained by governance, procurement, legal sign-off and static marketing budgets. One agency executive said an agency AI platform has grown revenue triple digits for five consecutive quarters, but clients fall into four camps—from active builders to outright dismissers—leaving a widening gap. Analysts say advertisers are demanding transparency about where AI is used. The reporting highlights tension between agency capability and advertiser readiness, with debate over whether agencies are genuinely ahead or using the narrative to justify fees.
Receive all future signals for Starling & competitors in your briefing
Never miss material M&A deals, leadership changes, account wins, or product rollouts. Polaris7 monitors 20,000+ primary sources 24/7, delivering verified telemetry directly into your executive briefing.
